The Perfect Tale
My Ebenezer Review

One of my ALL-TIME favorite stories is Charles Dickens’ incredible novella, “A Christmas Carol.” The story itself speaks to me on ALL levels. I love the era, London, the morality involved, and most wonderfully… the ending where we see Ebenezer’s redemption. It’s at THAT moment (usually the scenes at Fred Hollywell’s house) where I begin to weep as the emotions become overwhelming. No doubt fodder for discussion with my therapist in the near future🙃
Due to this great love for the story itself, I am quite likely the LAST person you should trust with a review of the new Johnny Depp vehicle “Ebenezer.” Indeed, as long as they follow Dicken’s narrative, I would enjoy seeing ANYONE in the lead roles!
I should also establish that I have a controversial pick for favorite Scrooge rendition. For me, that award will always go to George C. Scott and his 1984 adaptation. Even more so than the oft cited and iconic rendition by the marvelous Alastair Simm. The Scott version also benefits by the fact that it is wrapped in the warm nostalgia of watching it with my Mother and siblings in Hattiesburg every year for decades. It is to me, the perfect version.
But I love them ALL! From Mr. MaGoo to the Muppets, the story is just too good to render badly! It is the ultimate tale of reclamation and recovery that makes my heart soar like a hawk every single time. I also believe it to represent the teachings of Jesus in a nutshell (Hmmm “Jesus in a Nutshell” is an EXCELLENT name for a future article… stay tuned!)
Why then has Depp’s Ebenezer received wildly mixed reviews with a Rotten Tomato rating of only 54%🤔 Well, if you are looking for a version that departs drastically from Dickens, then you won’t like this film. Why I wonder would anyone deviate starkly from the Dickensian perfection of the original? Do we do the same with Shakespeare and Beethoven? Era and setting yes, but dialogue or notes? There are many great stories that are influenced by the originals and then go into fascinating new places, but in the case of A Christmas Carol, I personally prefer a preservation of at least 80% of the archetypal text.
Therefore, I give this new Ti West, Nathaniel Halpren adaptation an A PLUS on ALL levels! The ACTING! WOWZA (and GREAT GOOGLY MOOGLY Y’ALL) is world class from everyone:

Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge – top-billed lead, a miserly Victorian businessman forced on a supernatural journey of redemption on Christmas Eve.

Rupert Grint portrays Bob Cratchit – main cast, Scrooge’s overworked clerk who endures grueling labor while caring for his family.

Ian McKellen plays Jacob Marley – main cast, Scrooge’s associate who appears in connection with the haunting.

Andrea Riseborough portrays Ghost of Christmas Past – main cast, a spectral visitor who guides Scrooge through memories from his past.

Tramell Tillman plays Ghost of Christmas Present – main cast, a spirit who confronts Scrooge with the realities of the present day. [1, 2, 3, 4]
What-the-WHAT? Just seeing Sir Ian deliver the words “You will be haunted” as the ghost of Jacob Marley is worth the price of addmission for me😛 But EVERYONE brings something delightful to their portrayals.
Including:
- Sam Claflin plays Fred – main cast, Scrooge’s nephew who hopes to connect with his uncle and feel closer to his late mother.
- Daisy Ridley portrays Clara – main cast, a featured character in the Dickensian adaptation.
- Ellie Bamber plays Belle – main cast, a figure from Scrooge’s past.
- Charlie Murphy portrays Emily Cratchit – featured cast member, a member of the Cratchit family.
- Arthur Conti plays Young Ebenezer – featured cast member, portraying a younger version of Scrooge.
- Freddie Lee-Grey portrays Tiny Tim – featured cast member, a young member of the Cratchit household
The screenplay by Nathaniel Halpren achieves my 80% Dickensian text benchmark nicely, and Ti’s directing allows all of these powerhouse actors to have fun in their respective sandboxes…as it should be! The score by Tyler Bates (known for his work in the horror genre) is lovely here. I especially enjoyed the opening theme as we get our first look at old London in the fog. Tyler’s music is never overwhelming and (in my opinion) not necessarily as memorable melodically as a Jerry Goldsmith effort, but it certainly does what great “incidental music” should do in a film…it enhances the moment beautifully.
And the imagery on the screen! OY!!!! From all I’ve read about this era in England, it’s as if we had “worm hole cameras” that could actually film everything as it was in real time in the actual past. (yep, I stole THAT concept from one of my favorite books “The Light of Other Days” by Arthur C. Clarke and Stephen Baxter)
Ebenezer boasts delightful eye-candy of the highest order!
As you may now plainly see, I LOVED this version of A Christmas Carol and recommend it HIGHLY! ‘Tis an instant classic. Go out and SEE IT IN THEATERS ASAP!!!!
And God bless us all, EVERYONE!”